Beyond the Touchline
Football Training Gear

American football practice gear for footwork, catching, and the details that never make the highlights.

Kick Here

Thank You Sponsors.

Bryce Underwood's shaky start raises concerns for Michigan's future

Sep 7, 2026
Bryce Underwood's shaky start raises concerns for Michigan's future

The Michigan Wolverines faced a nail-biting finish against Western Michigan, with Bryce Underwood at the center of the drama. As the clock hit zero, it appeared that Michigan had suffered a shocking defeat, trailing 12-7. Underwood's hail mary attempt sailed out of bounds, seemingly sealing the game for the Broncos. However, after a review, officials reversed the call, allowing Underwood one final chance to redeem himself. He connected with JJ Buchanan for a touchdown, clinching a 13-12 victory for Michigan, but the controversy surrounding the officiating left many questioning the integrity of the outcome.

The Big Ten conference later clarified that the review determined a Western Michigan player had interfered with the ball just before the clock expired. This decision, however, has reignited discussions about Michigan's perceived favoritism in officiating, a sentiment echoed by fans and analysts alike. The narrative surrounding Michigan's reputation for receiving favorable calls adds another layer of scrutiny to Underwood's performance.

Beyond the Touchline
Football Training Gear
Kick Here
American Footballs
Kick Here
Football Books
Kick Here

Thank You Sponsors.

Despite the victory, Underwood's individual statistics raise significant concerns. He completed 12 of 22 passes for 170 yards, with one touchdown and one interception, resulting in a QBR of 54.1. Had the game concluded as initially ruled, his numbers would have been even less impressive: 11 completions on 21 attempts for just 123 yards. These figures are particularly troubling given that they came against a MAC-level defense, which typically does not pose the same challenges as higher-tier opponents.

Underwood, who is projected to be the top overall pick in the 2028 , has not yet lived up to the lofty expectations set for him. Last season, he struggled with a completion rate of just 60.3%, throwing 11 touchdowns against 9 interceptions. His performance against Western Michigan, where he was graded as the lowest offensive player by Pro Football Focus (PFF) with a score of 31.4, raises alarms about his readiness for the next level.

Underwood's performance sparks historical comparisons

Critics are already drawing comparisons between Underwood and Ron Powlus, the highly touted Notre Dame quarterback from the early 1990s who ultimately failed to meet expectations. Powlus was once heralded as a future Heisman Trophy winner but never achieved the success predicted for him. This comparison, while perhaps premature, highlights the pressure Underwood faces as he navigates his collegiate career.

As the Michigan fanbase reacts to Underwood's performance, calls for his benching are surfacing. While some may view this as an overreaction, it underscores the urgency for Underwood to improve. The stakes are high, not just for his personal aspirations but also for Michigan's season as they aim to compete at a national level. The upcoming games will be crucial for Underwood to demonstrate that he can rise to the occasion and fulfill the promise that has been placed upon him.

In conclusion, while Michigan's last-minute victory may have masked some of the issues, the reality of Underwood's performance cannot be ignored. As the season progresses, it will be essential for him to refine his skills and prove that he can handle the pressures of being a top quarterback prospect.

Beyond the Touchline
Football Training Gear

American football practice gear for footwork, catching, and the details that never make the highlights.

Kick Here
American Footballs

Footballs for drills, warm-ups, and backyard heroics. Audibles are optional; a decent spiral is welcome.

Kick Here

Thank You Sponsors.

Recommended for You
Ryan Clark critiques Arch Manning's first-round draft potential
American Football Nov 16, 2026

Ryan Clark critiques Arch Manning's first-round draft potential

Ryan Clark, a former NFL player, has expressed skepticism about Arch Manning's prospects as a first-round NFL draft pick. Despite…

Beyond the Touchline
Football Training Gear

American football practice gear for footwork, catching, and the details that never make the highlights.

Kick Here
American Footballs

Footballs for drills, warm-ups, and backyard heroics. Audibles are optional; a decent spiral is welcome.

Kick Here
Football Books

Playbooks, coaching ideas, and NFL history. There is a little more to the game than yelling 'go for it.'

Kick Here
Quarterback Passing Targets

Throwing targets and practice nets for the passing game. A target that cannot complain about the play call.

Kick Here
American Football Receiver Gloves

Receiver gloves for the next practice or game. Catching the ball remains a separate responsibility.

Kick Here
Flag Football Sets & Belts

Flag sets and belts for pickup games and organized practice. The arguments about who was open are included free.

Kick Here

Thank You Sponsors.

Across our publications

In Other News

Latest stories from other publications.

Explore all publications (opens in a new tab)