Seven Underrated Quarterbacks to Watch in College Football
As the 2025 college football season unfolds, several underrated quarterbacks are poised to make a significant impact. From LaNorris Sellers to Keawe-Sagapolutele, these players could emerge as top prospects for the NFL Draft, showcasing their talent and potential in the coming year.
The landscape of college football can shift dramatically in just a few months, and the 2025 season is no exception. While names like Arch Manning and Dante Moore dominate the headlines, several underrated quarterbacks are quietly positioning themselves for breakout seasons. Among them is LaNorris Sellers, who, along with Cade Klubnik and Garrett Nussmeier, was once viewed as a first-round prospect. However, the spotlight has largely overlooked Fernando Mendoza, a name that only a select few fans recognize, particularly those who witnessed his thrilling matchups against Cam Ward at Cal.
As the season progresses, it is likely that at least one lesser-known quarterback will rise to prominence, potentially entering the Heisman Trophy conversation or garnering first-round NFL Draft discussions. The journey to stardom is challenging, but several quarterbacks have the talent to follow in Mendoza's footsteps.
One such player is Jaden Craig, a Harvard transfer who led a potent offense for the Crimson. Over two seasons as a starter, he threw for 2,869 yards with only 10 interceptions in 611 attempts. Standing at 6-3, Craig possesses a strong frame and has shown promising arm strength as he transitions to TCU. If he meets or exceeds expectations, he could emerge as a legitimate NFL Draft prospect.
CJ Bailey, another name to watch, had a rocky season at NC State but demonstrated significant improvement. At 6-6, his height is an asset, though his slight frame raises concerns for NFL scouts. If he can refine his game and eliminate inconsistencies, Bailey could become one of the most exciting quarterbacks in the nation.
Drake Lindsey, who took over for Max Brosmer at Minnesota, is also generating buzz. With 18 touchdowns and only six interceptions last season, Lindsey finished strong, completing 66% of his passes without an interception in his final five games. At just 21 years old, he has the potential to return for another season and elevate his draft stock significantly.
Quarterbacks seeking redemption in new systems
DJ Lagway's journey has been tumultuous since his time at Florida, where he struggled with turnovers. However, a fresh start in a new offensive system could reignite his career. Now 21, Lagway has the opportunity to showcase his skills in a less daunting conference, allowing him to build confidence and potentially reclaim his status as a top prospect.
Cutter Boley's situation at Kentucky was challenging last season, but his performances against top teams like Tennessee and Georgia showed flashes of his potential. With a new coaching staff in place, Boley could thrive in a more supportive environment, making him a player to watch as he develops.
Finally, Keawe-Sagapolutele, who had a rocky start at Cal, is already being touted as a potential first-round pick in the 2028 NFL Draft. Despite early struggles, he finished strong, throwing for 3,454 yards and showcasing impressive arm talent. With a new head coach, this could be the season he truly breaks out.
As these quarterbacks embark on their respective journeys, the 2025 college football season promises to be filled with surprises. The emergence of these underrated talents could reshape the landscape of college football and the NFL Draft, proving that sometimes the most exciting stories come from the players who fly under the radar.
