Beyond the Touchline
Football Training Gear

American football practice gear for footwork, catching, and the details that never make the highlights.

Kick Here

Thank You Sponsors.

Ryan Clark critiques Arch Manning's first-round draft potential

Nov 16, 2026
Ryan Clark critiques Arch Manning's first-round draft potential

Texas Longhorns quarterback Arch Manning made headlines with a dramatic game-winning touchdown against LSU, sealing a 22-21 victory for his team. However, his overall performance during the game has drawn sharp criticism from former NFL player Ryan Clark, who believes that no NFL scout could responsibly label Manning as a first-round draft pick based solely on his current play.

Manning's stats from the game reveal a mixed performance: he completed 19 of 35 passes for 174 yards, with one touchdown and three interceptions, alongside 35 rushing yards and another score on 12 carries. While the final moments showcased his potential, Clark argues that the entirety of Manning's performance cannot be overlooked. He stated that recommending Manning as a first-round pick would be a "dereliction of duty" for any scout, emphasizing that the name and pedigree associated with Manning should not overshadow the actual performance captured on tape.

Beyond the Touchline
Football Training Gear
Kick Here
American Footballs
Kick Here
Football Books
Kick Here

Thank You Sponsors.

The Longhorns' victory improved their record to 8-2, but it has been a season of ups and downs for Manning, who entered the year as a highly touted prospect. In a midseason poll conducted by ESPN among NFL scouts and executives, Manning failed to receive any votes as the top quarterback likely to be selected in the 2027 draft. One scout even remarked that "Arch has fallen," indicating a significant drop in expectations for the young quarterback.

Concerns over Manning's future trajectory

Clark's critique comes in the wake of discussions about Manning's future, including suggestions from analysts like Todd McShay, who proposed that transferring to another program might help Manning enhance his draft stock. This reflects a growing concern that Manning's current trajectory may not align with the lofty expectations set for him at the start of the season.

No Points for Excuses

As a Super Bowl champion with the Pittsburgh Steelers, Clark brings a wealth of experience to his analysis. He has been vocal about the challenges Manning faces, stating, "There’s no way an NFL scout can responsibly walk into a draft room, stand on the table, and tell a GM that Arch Manning is a first-round pick." His comments underscore the importance of consistent performance over mere potential, a sentiment that resonates deeply in the competitive landscape of college football.

Manning still has opportunities to reshape his narrative as the season progresses. However, with the scrutiny intensifying and expectations weighing heavily, he must demonstrate that he can deliver not just in clutch moments but consistently throughout games. The road ahead is critical for Manning, as he seeks to prove that he can live up to the hype and secure his place among the top prospects for the upcoming NFL draft.

Beyond the Touchline
Football Training Gear

American football practice gear for footwork, catching, and the details that never make the highlights.

Kick Here
American Footballs

Footballs for drills, warm-ups, and backyard heroics. Audibles are optional; a decent spiral is welcome.

Kick Here

Thank You Sponsors.

Recommended for You
Texas Longhorns Coach Considers Benching Arch Manning Amid Struggles
American Football Oct 20, 2026

Texas Longhorns Coach Considers Benching Arch Manning Amid Struggles

After two consecutive losses, Texas Longhorns head coach Steve Sarkisian is contemplating a quarterback change due to Arch Manning's…

Beyond the Touchline
Football Training Gear

American football practice gear for footwork, catching, and the details that never make the highlights.

Kick Here
American Footballs

Footballs for drills, warm-ups, and backyard heroics. Audibles are optional; a decent spiral is welcome.

Kick Here
Football Books

Playbooks, coaching ideas, and NFL history. There is a little more to the game than yelling 'go for it.'

Kick Here
Quarterback Passing Targets

Throwing targets and practice nets for the passing game. A target that cannot complain about the play call.

Kick Here
American Football Receiver Gloves

Receiver gloves for the next practice or game. Catching the ball remains a separate responsibility.

Kick Here
Flag Football Sets & Belts

Flag sets and belts for pickup games and organized practice. The arguments about who was open are included free.

Kick Here

Thank You Sponsors.

Across our publications

In Other News

Latest stories from other publications.

Explore all publications (opens in a new tab)